One Kenyan distributor had even petitioned the country’s standards bureau to complain about the quality of some of the products on China Square’s shelves. The standards bureau found the product to be genuine and from the same manufacturer. The Kenyan distributor was selling them at a much higher price compared to China Square.
If you are an ardent follower of regional news, you have most likely come across China Square, a popular retailer located inside Kenyatta University’s Unicity Shopping Mall in Nairobi. China Square has been in the news for committing the "heinous" crime of selling its wares way cheaper than Kenyan traders, prompting action from Kenya’s Cabinet Secretary for Trade. The secretary said foreigners should be involved in manufacturing, not running retail outlets in glitzy shopping malls.
Recommended articles
Buoyed by the revelations of the standards authority, many Kenyans, as they usually do, turned to Twitter to argue that Kenyan traders were charging too much for the same product and that they had no problem buying from China Square.
Back home in Uganda, many foreign traders, particularly from Asia, have set up shop in every little building known as an arcade or mall. Ugandan traders also complain about the Indians and the Chinese undercutting them with cheaper prices, though being Uganda, these complaints haven’t received the attention of a minister or permanent secretary.
But what makes products of Ugandan traders from the same manufacturers expensive? There is the issue of high interest rates on bank loans. It is inconceivable how a trader borrowing money at highs of 25% can be able to trade and survive. Some even go to informal money lenders who charge as much as 10% per month or 120% annually. Unless you are selling contraband, it is not possible to do business where the loan interest rate is 5-10% per month. It is a license to fail.
The foreigners are usually coming in with loans at under 3% annually. Many actually don’t even have loans; they are using supplier’s credit, where suppliers and manufacturers give them goods on credit to pay back in a particular period long after the goods have been sold off. Many Ugandans also have access to supplier’s credit, though we are good at abusing it.
Many Ugandans, once they get goods on credit once or twice, change numbers and location. Eventually, they become endlessly broke and blame everyone but themselves. If you think this isn’t the case, how many people have borrowed money from you and paid it back? Or even paid it on time?
If people complain when you send them money on their mobile phone without asking them which number to send to (because they don’t want to pay back), what about a supplier in the Far East? So we end up all the time looking for money to pay new suppliers instead of cementing lasting relationships with the one who has been extending goods on credit.
Then there’s the cost of doing business. In downtown Kampala, you will find four traders or more renting one shop, but each is suspicious of the others. So, each of these four traders flies to China, Dubai, or Turkey to bring the same product. That is four air tickets, four hotel rooms (or some shanty digs in Deira), instead of one. The foreigners would send one person to do the shopping. In fact, they wouldn’t even send anyone—they would simply send an email, and goods are shipped in.
A foreigner who saves four air tickets and accommodation for a week will certainly sell their merchandise at a cheaper rate. Ugandan traders must create lasting collaborations with suppliers and also embrace technology.
And then, of course, our other weaknesses, such as diverting money for self-actualization projects: a house in the village in which we spend less than 10 nights a year, a wedding worthy of a top member of the royal family, a residential house in the city the size (and even shape) of a midsize shopping mall, a fancy but old SUV, a mistress in each corner of Kampala (for men), and a long line of children.
As many Kenyan traders are building and buying fancy apartments, the China Square people are most likely renting one within walking distance to their shop and only have a few children.
The writer is a communication and visibility consultant. djjuuko@gmail.com. This article was originally written on March 23, 2023.